Wednesday, April 26, 2006
POLICE LINE-UPS QUESTIONED
By Stockton
For years, the efficacy of eye-witness testimony in criminal cases has been in doubt. Over time, studies have shown that witnesses to a crime often make unreliable witnesses, especially when picking a perpetrator from a line-up. It is not uncommon for multiple witnesses to choose multiple suspects from the same line-up. Now, studies are casting doubt on other studies, making us all very confused.
The upshot of all this is, eye-witnesses and studies on eye-witnesses are unreliable. Which goes a long way in explaining why Jacob Stoodle,
was arrested for a crime allegedly committed by,
Joshua Rosen (who turned out to have been 2,000 miles away at the time of the incident anyway).
The two now correspond and are good friends.
For years, the efficacy of eye-witness testimony in criminal cases has been in doubt. Over time, studies have shown that witnesses to a crime often make unreliable witnesses, especially when picking a perpetrator from a line-up. It is not uncommon for multiple witnesses to choose multiple suspects from the same line-up. Now, studies are casting doubt on other studies, making us all very confused.
The upshot of all this is, eye-witnesses and studies on eye-witnesses are unreliable. Which goes a long way in explaining why Jacob Stoodle,
was arrested for a crime allegedly committed by,
Joshua Rosen (who turned out to have been 2,000 miles away at the time of the incident anyway).
The two now correspond and are good friends.